Monday 14 July 2014

166 Hello The Bee Gees - New York Mining Disaster 1941


Chart  entered  : 27  April  1967

Chart  peak : 12

Number  of  hits : 38

Well  the  big  names  are  coming  thick  and  fast  now. Like  Englebert  this  lot  have  a  lengthy  pre-fame  catalogue  to  wade  through  but  I  expect  it  to  be  a  bit  more  rewarding.

The  three  Gibb  brothers  were  born  on  the  Isle  of  Man  , Barry  in  1946, the  twins  Robin  and  Maurice in  1946. The  family  moved  to  Chorlton,  Manchester  in  1955, then  Australia  in  1958. From  some  versions  of  the  story  you'd  think  they  were  transported  but  in  truth  they  did  nothing  exceptional  in  a  rather  rough   neighbourhood ( My  mum  came  from  there  originally )  and   the  twins  were  below  the  age  of  criminal  responsibility  anyway.  As  a  singing  trio  they  got  their  first  break  entertaining  crowds  at  a  Brisbane  speedway  track  in  1960 by  a  promoter  called  Bill  Goode  and  named  by  his  similarly initialled  DJ  friend  Bill  Gates  ( not  that  one ).

By  the  end  of  the  year  they  were  a  TV  act. In  1962  they  were  the  support  act  for  Chubby Checker at  Sydney  Stadium.  They  attracted  the  attention  of  Australian  rocker  Col  Joye  who  got them  a  record  deal  with  Leedon  Records  in  1963.

Their  first  single  was  "The  Battle  Of  The  Blue And  The  Grey"  in  March  1963 , a  country  hoedown  about  the  American  Civil  War   that  proves  that,  even  at  16 , Barry  Gibb  could  write  a  song  in  any  style  he  chose. Time  to  work  on  those  grating  adenoidal  vocals  then.

"Timber !" which  comes  in  at  just  1:47  sounds  like  Joe  Brown  played  at  the  wrong  speed. They're on  to  the  second  chorus  before  the  30  second  mark. "Peace  Of  Mind"  from  February  1964  is  a  juvenile  impersonation  of  the  Beatles  with  painfully  raw  harmonies. "Claustrophobia"  sounds  more  like  Freddie  and  the  Dreamers  though  the  vocal  sound   is  improving  by  this  point.

In  October  1964  they  tried  a  cover  of  Glen  Campbell's  "Turn  Around , Look  At  Me"   which  has   a  big  production  job  and  a  confident  lead  vocal  from  Barry.  The  single  was  actually  released  under  the  name  "Barry  Gibb  and  the  Bee-Gees.

At  the  beginning  of  1965  they  backed  another  teen   act  Trevor  Gordon   ( who  sounds  like  Gerry Marsden )   on  "House Of  Windows "  ( Barry's  song ).  It's  acceptable  beat  pop  , perhaps  a  little dated  for  its  time.

They  stuck  with  a  cover  and  Barry's  name  out  front  in  April  with  Arthur  Alexander's  "Everyday  I  Have  To  Cry"  which  for  the  first  time  featured  a  lead  vocal  from  Robin  and  some  keyboards  from  Maurice. The   lads  give  it  a  lightly  Caribbean  flavour  possibly  influenced  by  The  Seekers.

By  this  time  the  record  company  were  beginning  to  have  doubts  about  their  investment  so  it  was well  that  "Wine  And  Women"  made a  dent  in  the  Australian  charts, peaking  at  number  19. You  can tell  they're  moving  up  a  gear  with  the  harmonic  arrangement   and  the  melodic  richness on  this stoical song in  waltz  time.  The  brief  guitar  solo  unveils  that  bottom  end  guitar  sound  they'd  deploy  on  Massachusetts. The  sleeve  tells  us  that  "The  Bee  Gee's  ( sic ) main  ambition  is  to  last  in  popularity  as  long  as  the  Mills  Brothers  " - I  think  you  can  tick  that  one  off  now , Barry.

"I  Was  A  Lover  A  Leader  Of  Men"   sticks  with  the  waltz  time  for  a  hubristic  downfall  song  which  incorporates  some  distorted  guitar  blasts  borrowed  from  early  Kinks. Strangely  the  label  trumpets  that  it  features  the  Farfisa  Portable  Electronic  Organ  but  its  use  seems  to  be  limited  to  a  few  seconds  in  the  fadeout  when  you  can  hardly  hear  it.

The  group  were  at  this  point  being  courted  by  Nat  Kipner , an  American  expatriate  who  had  just  set  up  his  own  label,  Spin. His  son   Steve  had  put  a  band  together , Steve  And  The  Board,  who  naturally  enough  landed  on  his  dad's  label. Their  drummer  was  Colin  Petersen ( born  1946 )  who'd  already  made  a  name  for  himself  as  a  child  actor  in  the  fifties   particularly  in  Smiley  (1956 )  which  was  a  big  hit  in  Britain.

Their  first  single  "The  Giggle-Eyed  Goo"  also  came  out  in  November  and  is  a  slice  of  Kingsmen-style  garage  rock  with  a  nonsense  lyric  and  gonzoid  sped-up  passages. It's  constrained  by  Steve  Kipner's   just    adequate  vocal. "Margot"  from  March  1966  has  a  more  harmony-based  approach  but  the  song  is  very  slight,  being  little  more  than  a  vehicle  for  the  guitarist  Carl  Groseman  to  play  some  Stones-y  licks. Colin  gets  a  chance  to  draw  up  some  thunder  on  the  middle  eight.

The  Bee  Gees  owed  one  more  single  to  Leedon, "I  Want  Home"  which  was  released  in  March  1966. Here  they  appropriate  the  garage  rock  sound  for  themselves  and  also  borrowed  Colin  for  the  recording  session. He  lays  down  the  heavy  backbeat, especially  prominent  on  the  chorus, while  Maurice  gets  to  lay  down  some  meaty  licks  on  the  guitar. It's  not  one  of  Barry's  best  songs  to  be  honest.

Their  first  single  on  Spin  was  "Monday's  Rain"  with  new  producer  Ossie  Byrne  in  June. It's  an   unintentionally  amusing  attempt  to  emulate  the  Walker  Brothers. Robin  doing  a  Scott  Walker  vocal has  to be  heard  to  be  believed.  The  underlying  song  isn't  too  bad  but  it's  impossible  to  take  the record seriously. As  a  side  note   I  have  absolutely  no  idea  what  the  instrument  in  the  middle  eight  is  - perhaps  a  certain  bearded  paedo  dropped  in  on  the  session ?  

Steve  and  the  Board's  single  at  the  same  time  was, ahem, "I  Call  My  Woman  Hinges  Cause  She's Something  To  Adore"  ( hilariously  Grozeman  had  now  changed  his  surname  to  Keats  so  that appears  alongside  Kipner  on  the  writing  credits ) . It's  not  quite  as  bad  as  the  title  suggests  - how could  it  be ? " - but  their  sound  is  a  bit  retarded  for  1966. Colin's  last  single  with  the  band  was  "Now  I'm  Older"; he'd  already  set  off  for  England  when  it  was  released  in  September. Written  by  Carl  Keats  it's  both  musically  and  lyrically  a  homage  to  The  Byrds  with  Colin  tapping  away  at  a  cowbell  throughout  the  song.

That  same  month  The  Bee-Gees  released  "Spicks  And  Specks"  a  jaunty  piece  of  pyschedelic  pop  based  on  Maurice's  simple  piano  riff  which  gradually  builds  up  into  something  of  a  tour  de  force  with  Geoff  Grant's  trumpet  a  key  factor. The  song  also  borrows  a  harmony  line  from  Pachelbel's  Canon. Ironically  the  brothers  had  already  decided  to  return  to  England  and  followed  its  progress  up  the  Australian  charts  to  number  four  from  on  board  a  ship. It  went  to  number  one  in  New  Zealand  and  was  also  a  hit  in  Germany  and  Holland.

Their  father  had  made  contact  to  Brian  Epstein  beforehand  and  he  passed  their  tapes  on  to  his  business  associate  Robert  Stigwood. He  briefly  auditioned  them  shortly  after  their  arrival  in  England.
By  the  time  he  had  got  them  a  deal  with  Polydor  in  February  1967  they  were  a  four  piece  as Colin  had  been  invited  to  join  the  group. Polydor  acquired  the  rights  to  issue  "Spicks  And  Specks"  as  their  first  single  in  the  UK  but  it  didn't  do  anything.

This  one  was  their  second. "New  York  Mining  Disaster 1941"  was  inspired  by  a  power  cut   while the  band  were  at  Polydor's  studios  and  the  boys'  thoughts  turned  to  being  trapped  in  a  confined space. Maurice  also  later  suggested  that  the  Aberfan  tragedy  in  1966  was  an  inspiration. New  York was  presumably  chosen  as  the  scene   for  marketing  reasons  ( it  worked ).

It's  an  ambitious  song  beginning  with  the  lone  Hawaiian  guitar  chord  before  Robin's  vulnerable   voice  begins  "In  the  event  of  something  happening  to  me...". He  then  goes  on  to  describe  showing a  family  photograph  to  his  colleague  Mr  Jones  as  hopes of  rescue  fade.  The  chorus , where  Colin's drums  kick  in  suggests  something  more  hopeful  but  the  next  two  verses  get  increasingly  mournful with  a  violin   at  times  the  only  accompaniment. To  have  an  early  summer  hit  with  something  so strange  and  downbeat  was  quite  an  achievement.

Stigwood  did  pull  a  few  stunts  to  get  it  played. Some  copies  went  out  to  radio  stations  without  a  label  but  the  information  that  it  was  by  an  English  group  beginning  with  B  and  some  of  them  played  it  thinking  it  might  be  The  Beatles. There  is  a  slight  debt  to  Eleanor  Rigby  but  I  don't  know  which  Beatle  they  imagined  was  singing  it. A  promo  film  was  made, once  that  nonsense  was  over, notable  for  its  democracy ( Colin , in  felt  hat,  gets his  fair  share  of  attention ) and  Barry's  remarkable  resemblance  to  the  actor  Colin  Welland.

The  song  stayed  in  their  live  set   throughout  their  career  and  Barry  performed  it  on  his  solo  tour  last  year. It's  also  been  attested  that  David  Bowe's  Space  Oddity   was   heavily  influenced  by  it.



  




No comments:

Post a Comment